A Miracle Out of
Nowhere: Phil Ehart Reflects on Leftoverture’s 35th Anniversary
By Jeb Wright
Kansas were six young men from Topeka, Kansas who had the crazy
notion that they could make a living playing rock n’ roll. None
of them were prototype rock stars, in fact, some were Plain
Jane's, some were overall wearing hicks and others fancied
Rollie Finger’s type mustachios. Singer Steve Walsh was the
closest thing to a pinup boy the band had. No one, not even the
band members, can explain why music mogul Don Kirshner signed
the six marauders to his record label in the mid-1970’s.
Kirshner was famous for The Monkees and The Archies, both of
which were a long way from being comparable to Kansas.
The band recorded three albums and toured coast-to-coast with
any band that would let them on the bill. Despite seeing each
album outsell it’s predecessor, the band were falling deeply in
debt and if a hit song didn’t happen, and soon, they would find
themselves back in Topeka, sitting on a barstool telling stories
of the good old days.
The band returned to Topeka and began work on what would
become Leftoverture. Unbeknownst to the rest of the band,
Kerry Livgren was about to go on a creative surge that would
keep Kansas on the road for the next 35 plus years. It seems the
Rock Gods opened up the clouds and gave the blonde haired muse
the inspiration to create the best songs he had ever written.
The band watched enthusiastically as Livgren topped his best
song ever written on a daily basis.
Still, as good as the music was, there was no apparent hit
single. With this in mind, the members of Kansas packed up their
gear for the drive to The Studio in the Country in Bogalusa,
Louisiana to record the new tracks. Before leaving, Livgren
announced to his fellow band members that he had one more new
song that he wanted to work up. That song turned out to be
“Carry On Wayward Son,” a fitting sentiment indeed. Don Kirshner
finally got that hit single he so desperately desired. “Carry On
Wayward Son” went Gold and reached # 11 on the Billboard Singles
Charts, while the parent album, Leftoverture reached # 5
on the Billboard Album Charts and sold multi-platinum.
In the interview that follows, Kansas drummer, Phil Ehart,
takes us back to Topeka and discusses the songs, the songwriting
and the success of Leftoverture.
Jeb: It has been 35 years since Leftoverture was
released. Does it seem like it has been that long?
Phil: It just hit me a couple of months ago, that it has been
that long. You know, that is a really good question, as I am not
sure what 35 years is supposed to feel like. Albums are a
snapshot of what was going on at that time. When we think of
Leftoverture, we can tell you where we were, what we were
doing, where we worked up the songs, and when we went down to
Bogalusa, Louisiana to record it, but we really can’t tell you
much about anything else from that time period. It is pretty to
cool to have things like that.
Jeb: The story of Leftoverture really begins with the
album, and tour, that came before it, Masque. As legend
holds, Don Kirshner was pressuring the band for a hit song.
Phil: It is a pretty well known fact that Leftoverture,
being our fourth album, had Don wanting us to have a hit. He had
had enough of the FM radio play, and of having us be an opening
band for seven thousands bands across the country. It wasn’t
really pressure. He would just say, “Guys, let’s try to get
something on the radio.” As it turned out “Carry on Wayward Son”
was that song.
Jeb: That almost didn’t happen.
Phil: It almost didn’t make it on the record. We had already
worked up, chosen, and rehearsed all of the songs that were
going on the record. We were packing up all of our gear and
Kerry [Livgren] said, “I have another song that I wasn’t to play
for you when we get down to the studio.” If he hadn’t have been
persistent, and not believed in the song himself, then it might
not have happened. Of course, as soon as we all heard it, we
worked it up immediately.
Jeb: Kerry was on a roll.
Phil: It was one of Kerry’s most prolific periods. Everyday,
we would just wait for Kerry to show up and then we would all be
going, “What do you have today? Do you have another new song?”
Jeb: I have heard that you were still based out of Topeka,
Kansas.
Phil: We were still in Topeka, well, some of us had relocated
to Atlanta, but we were back in Topeka for rehearsals. We
actually worked up the music in a vacant store in a strip mall.
I don’t remember exactly where it was, but I remember the place
well in my mind.
Jeb: For six guys from Kansas, you had done well with the
first three albums, yet you were not able to break big.
Phil: The first album sold 50,000, the second had done
100,000 and Masque sold 150,000. We gained a lot from
being an opening act, and FM radio was playing the heck out of
our longer cuts. Kirshner wasn’t losing money on our albums, but
we were not making enough money, on the road, to pay for being
on the road. He was providing tour support and when you’re
playing 300 gigs a year, then that gets expensive. I think
before Leftoverture, we were a half a million dollars
down. Today, that would not be considered a lot of money, but in
‘70’s money that was a lot. Our touring expenses were really
starting to build up and I don’t think Don was willing to keep
doing that. We were really lucky that it hit when it did.
Jeb: Did Kerry bring finished songs to rehearsal or was it
more of a work in progress?
Phil: It was a work in progress. He knew we were coming up to
work on the album and he had a few songs and some ideas. After
the first three or four songs, then it got to the point that he
had to go home and write new songs, and come back the next day.
We would work on them, and then he would go home and write some
more. He was just very prolific. Steve was in a bit of a writing
slump at the time, but Kerry was hitting on all cylinders. All
of us just stood back and stayed out of his way. He would bring
in “What’s On My Mind” one day, and the next day he would bring
in “Cheyenne Anthem,” and the next day he would bring in “The
Wall,” and then he would bring in “Miracles Out of Nowhere.”
When you are on a roll like that, then you just stay out of the
way and let it happen.
Jeb: It sounds like Kerry was possessed and great songs were
flowing out of him.
Phil: It was the music, and the lyrics, and it was all the
best he had ever done. We would work on the arrangements, as a
band, but when he would bring in the songs, Rich [Williams]
would look at me, and I would look at him, and we would both
just go, “Whoa.” It was awesome. We just couldn’t get to it
quick enough and start playing. “Miracles Out of Nowhere” has
such an odd beginning to the song, with all the odd time
signatures in it. There were things like that, which were quite
difficult to really get the feel of and make it sound like a
rock song. There were a lot of different parts going on.
Jeb: “Miracles Out of Nowhere” is not just one of my favorite
Kansas songs; it is one of my favorite songs. It has so much
going on within it. When I am at your show, and I am standing
next to your drums, on the side of the stage, you amaze me. When
I am so close to your drums that I can hear them from you, and
not from the PA, then I am blown away at the power of that song,
and your drum parts.
Phil: It is hard to totally remember what happened back then.
None of us read music, so it was not like Kerry just wrote it
out for us. With a song like that, where Kerry put together so
many changes, then it makes it hard to play drums and keep it
all together. It is difficult to make sure it is a four-legged
dog running, and not a three-legged dog. We had to really work
at it; it was unlike anything we had ever played. We all feel
that is very much a prog type of song, but it also really rocks.
“Miracles Out of Nowhere” could be the quintessential Kansas
song. It has great lyrics and challenging music. It opens and it
has acoustic guitar, then it has the whole counterpoint thing in
the middle, then it breaks loose and rocks hard at the end. It
is like a movie in music. I am just proud to be a part of it. We
all kind of look at that song that way. It was interesting that
Robby [Steinhardt] sang it but Steve was also involved with the
vocals. “Miracles” worked every cylinder of the Kansas engine
that we had at the time.
Jeb: “Carry On Wayward Son” started off with all vocals. Was
that added later?
Phil: As I remember, one of the things we really liked about
it was that is started a Capella. One of the things that really
blew us away was when Steve went in to sing the opening. When we
came back a few hours later, with just him singing it, it
sounded like a brass section. It really just hit so hard. It was
a great beginning to a song that was unlike anything we had done
before. There are still a few songs that we play off that album
every night because they are still such a big part of the band.
Jeb: Does “Wayward Son” have more meaning, less meaning or
has it remained pretty consistent in it’s importance over the
years?
Phil: I would say it has been pretty consistent. What is
really funny is when we worked up that song we used to open our
show with it. We were pretty green back then. It was a hit and
we played it first in the set. We started noticing a large
section of the audience saying, “See ya” after we played it. We
decided we might be wise to move it back a bit in the set list.
That song has always been a big part of a Kansas show. I
can’t remember not playing it at a Kansas show since
Leftoverture was released. It is our biggest hit next to
“Dust in the Wind” and it is a killer song. We have always
enjoyed playing it.
You never get tired of playing it because of the audience
reaction that it gets. It is all about audience reaction. If we
don’t get a good audience reaction, then we usually drop the
song from the set. If you play your heart out, and you see the
audience talking to each other, then you know it’s not working.
That never happened with “Wayward Son.”
Jeb: “Cheyenne Anthem” is another crazy song. It goes from
morose to almost a polka.
Phil: And what awesome lyrics… Kerry just kind of whipped
them out. To this day, it’s almost a goose-bumpy song for us. As
you said earlier, that album really did start to grow out of
Masque. The seeds were sown on that album and the direction
for Leftoverture was set forth.
Jeb: “Icarus,” “The Pinnacle” and “Mysteries and Mayhem” were
all on Masque.
Phil: Those songs pretty much sow the seeds of
Leftoverture.
Jeb: “The Wall” is a great song and was a big hit. I am going
to guess that Kerry brought that song in a finished format to
the group. Am I correct?
Phil: The ending was from another song that he had written a
number of years earlier. Kerry had so many different parts and
pieces hanging around that a lot of the song could have come
from parts he had sitting around. It is a great song. Steve
really brought a lot to that song with the melodies and the way
that he sang it.
Jeb: “What’s On My Mind” is a great song as well, but you
never play that live. Why?
Phil: That song worked when Kerry was in the band because it
is about his wife. Once he retired and we moved on…it is a great
song and it has a great guitar riff, but it just didn’t really
work for us anymore. It wasn’t personal to any of us and there
were just other songs that we would rather do. It is a great
song on Leftoverture, though.
Jeb: Radio has forgotten “Opus Insert” and “Questions of My
Childhood.” I think “Questions” has a lot of what we talked
about with “Miracles Out of Nowhere” but it just doesn’t gel as
well.
Phil: No, it didn’t. We have played “Opus Insert” for a
number of years. The one thing that nails us on “Opus Insert” is
that it is so high for Steve to sing. If you listen to that, it
is so stratospheric that it takes a real toll on his voice. We
ended up having to just set that one aside. Luckily, there are a
lot of other great songs on Leftoverture to choose from.
Jeb: “Magnum Opus” is a wild one. It was fragments of other
songs. Tell me how that came together.
Phil: It was a lot of parts. At the time, Kerry was writing
all the time. If he wasn’t writing in the studio, he was at home
writing, and then he would get up in the morning and begin
writing. He would often bring in these parts. If they wouldn’t
work with anything, we would set them aside and do something
else. That song was actually going to be called “Left Over
Overture.” Dave [Hope] shortened it to “Leftoverture.” The song
was literally a bunch of leftovers. In-between cigarettes, Dave
said that, and we just went, “That is the name of the album.” We
used that as the album title, so we deiced to use “Magnum Opus,”
which is a phrase for a large musical piece for the name of the
song.
Jeb: Did you have to rewrite songs to certain keys, or speed
up and slow down tapes? How did you make it all mesh?
Phil: We just rehearsed it until we had it. None of our
songs, in the heyday, were ever spliced. We would count out and
play the songs all the way through, whether it was a four-minute
song, or a twelve-minute song, just to get a drum track. I would
play that twelve minute song nine times until there was nothing
left and we would then go and put the bass on. We never cut tape
and that is why you hear some of the imperfections.
If you listen to “Carry On Wayward Son,” when Kerry starts
the first verse with just the piano, he slows it way down. When
I come in then I pick it up a bit. It is nothing that you would
ever notice unless you listen for it. If you go back and listen
to that song, then you will hear it speed back up to the speed
that it is supposed to be. We didn’t have click tracks, and we
just played to feel. It is boring when it is the absolute
perfect tempo, from beginning to end. I think songs need to
breath. We would just rehearse, and rehearse, and rehearse, and
then, when we were ready, we would go to tape.
Jeb: Did you guys realize how good this album was?
Phil: Jeff Glixman is a great one to talk to that about.
Somebody asked him, “Do you think “Wayward Son” is a hit song,”
and he said, “If it wasn’t us, then I would think it was.” You
are so inside it that it is hard to step outside and see if it
is going to be a hit. You can’t tell when you’re on the inside.
Leftoverture had an amazing sonic quality with Jeff
Glixman producing and Bill Evans engineering. The way that album
sounds is, to this day, impressive.
Jeb: Was Glixman the ‘other band member’ as a producer?
Phil: He really was. We had played in local bands with him;
he was an organist. When we were going to hit the road and go
out with The Kinks, we called him because he had a great ear. I
asked him if he wanted to be our soundman.
In that Ryder truck, in the cab, was our three crew guys.
Jerry Gilleland was our drum tech. He went on to have a career
as a production manager with U2, The Rolling Stones, David Bowie
and ZZ Top, among others. Jeff produced albums that have sold
over sixty to seventy million copies. The other guy was Merle
McLain, who was the lighting guy for Journey, Yes and Michael
Jackson’s Thriller tour. All of those guys were from
Topeka. We had one heck of a road crew coming out of the little
town of Topeka, Kansas.
Jeb: Tell me the story behind the cover of the album.
Phil: Kirshner sent us some artists who wanted to do the
cover. One artist drew up some mock stuff and we loved the old
man with the sheet music that ran from the front cover, to the
back cover. We changed the logo up just a little bit. We thought
it was kind of a cool cover. We didn’t know it would become so
iconic. Of course, we didn’t know it would sell so many copies,
either.
The pictures inside just had the guys getting their picture
taken. It was just, “Okay, step into this light. Thanks. Next.”
It was like having your driver’s license picture taken. The art
directors at Sony were good and the pictures came out okay for a
bunch of ugly guys. We felt that we needed to identify
ourselves. On Masque, the pictures were dark and hard to
make out. Some of the guys looked different as well, so we just
thought we needed some good pictures of the guys. It was a very
simple package but that old man ended up taking on a life of his
own.
Jeb: I have never heard how Kirshner felt when he heard that
album for the first time?
Phil: Don was a pretty awesome guy, may he rest in peace. You
could have the six of us sitting at a table right now and nobody
could tell you what it was that he saw in us. We were such an
oddity. We were not singer/songwriters. We were not The Monkees
or The Archies. We were not like anything that he had ever
signed, or even been around. He was a publisher, and a song
plugger, and then he had a weird group of guys out in Topeka
that he was so passionate about. He really cared about us. He
was not fawning; he was not a back patter. He didn’t come into
the studio and pat Steve on the back and tell him what a great
singer he was. He looked at us almost like a peer, or an equal.
He was our label guy and we were the artist.
I don’t remember him saying anything about Leftoverture
when he got it. He must have liked it or he would have made us
go back and rerecord stuff. He would call down to the studio and
Jeff would hold the phone up and let Don hear what was going on.
Don would say, “Okay guys, it sounds great. Keep up the great
work. Give me a single; I could sure use a single. I love you
guys.”
We refereed to him as Uncle Don. He was really like a rich
uncle who would support you in whatever you wanted to do. When
he passed away, we all sat there and thought, “What would our
lives be like today if it hadn’t been for Don Kirshner?” His was
the only offer we ever got; it’s not like there was a bidding
war for Kansas. He was a great guy. He was never a whiner and he
never came down and shook his finger at us. He always wanted to
know what he could do to help us. I think we are one of the only
bands who ever had somebody like that; he was so singular. We
were the only band that he ever signed to his label. He also
signed Lisa Hartman, who is Clint Black’s wife. We have always
said that if we ever run into Clint that we want to make sure to
let him know we were label mates with his wife.
Jeb: How do you feel Kerry was able to pull this off, looking
back?
Phil: When the members of the band write the songs, then
there is a window of about ten to fifteen years where most of
the great stuff happens; the stuff that is around forever. There
are exceptions to that but most bands will show that is true.
Most writers will tell you that there is a time period where
they were very prolific, and that they were never able to
recreate that again. There is a time where everything is
wonderful, and then it gets a little less wonderful, and you
move downhill from there. Every once in a while you, will write
something that kicks the meter again, but most writers will tell
you there is a period of their career where they were more
prolific than they were at other times.
Jeb: How long did it take when the album came out to being
able to be a headliner instead of an opening act?
Phil: We had been working hard as an opener and we had just
been able to touch some areas where we could headline small
theaters. When “Carry On Wayward Son” hit, it was so big and so
fast that it was almost overnight. Luckily, we had been playing
so much, over 300 shows a year, that the transition was not bad.
The one thing that helped us the most was playing forty dates
with Queen. Those dates gave our lighting and sound guys the
ability to pace a show and to see how a show should go. By the
time we hit Leftoverture, we had learned a lot from Queen
on how to do it. We also learned a lot from Bad Company. It
wasn’t easy by any means, but we were ready. We had over six
hundred shows under our belt as an opener, so we knew what we
wanted to do as a headliner, and we knew how to do it thanks to
the bands that we were working with.
Jeb: How did you handle the sudden notoriety and money?
Phil: It happened so fast that we didn’t really have a lot of
time to think about it. I remember our manager, Bud Carr,
walking into the dressing room one night and saying, “You have a
hit song.” We all looked at him with surprise, and he said,
“’Carry On Wayward Son’ is a hit. It is climbing up the charts
in the Northeast.” It hit some major radio stations and it just
exploded.
We didn’t come home for two and half to three years. It was
across the States to Japan, to Europe, back to the States, back
to Japan, back to Europe and up to Canada. We didn’t really have
a chance to think, “We are really doing well.” It was just “Go!”
We got up there and played our ass off every night, slept, got
up, and played our ass off again. Right after that, we had
Point of Know Return, which had “Dust in the Wind,” which
was even a bigger song than “Carry On Wayward Son.” We had six
to seven years of constant touring.
Jeb: I remember growing up in Topeka and it was Kansas-mania
back then.
Phil: Rich and I went back to our high school reunion during
the Point of Know Return tour. Rich and I were such naïve
guys back then. We just thought, “Let’s go back to Topeka West
for our ten year reunion and see how our friends are.” We never
thought what they thought of us. We just thought we would be
Phil and Rich, who were a couple of idiots in high school. Well,
it wasn’t quite that way. Most of our classmates had our albums
with them for us to sign. We had no idea. We were truly naive.
We just showed up to hang with everybody else.
That afternoon, we had been onstage with the Rolling Stones
with ninety thousands people in the audience. You run into your
classmates and you say, “So what are you up to?” They say, “I’ve
got a job at Sears.” You reply, “I was just onstage with ninety
thousand people with The Rolling Stones.” We didn’t actually do
that [laughter]. It was a real culture shock. We had never
thought of ourselves as being famous, or being that big of a
deal. It really shocked us. We eventually left, as it was just
too uncomfortable. It was very odd. That is when we first
started getting the thought that we were getting fairly famous.
I mean we couldn’t even talk to our old classmates without
signing autographs. Fame wasn’t anything that any of us were
ever comfortable with. It was more inconvenient than anything
else.
Jeb: Last one: Is Leftoverture your favorite Kansas
album?
Phil: I think I could honestly say that, as an overall album,
Leftoverture is my favorite album. That includes the
sound of it, the performances, the songs that were written, the
lyrics and the liner notes. I don’t know if it was our high
point, it was pretty darn close. I think if someone were to ask,
“What was Kansas like?” Then that is the album I would give
them. You would miss having “Song For America” on there, and you
would miss “Dust in the Wind” and some things like that.
Overall, I think that is the one. Leftoverture doesn’t
really have a ballad on it. It wasn’t until “Dust” and later
“Hold On” that we did ballads. At that time, we were more about
just going out there and rocking hard. Overall though, I would
say Leftoverture is the one.
Jeb: Rock nerds like myself have debated if the best was
Leftoverture or Point of Know Return, or even Song
For America for years. I think for me, it depends on what
day it is and what mood I am in.
Phil: You’re right. There are times where my favorite album
we have ever done is In the Spirit of Things. It just
depends on the mood I am in and what I want to hear. I love the
Power album as it was a really cool time period.
Freaks of Nature has some interesting songs on it. There are
different time periods where there are things that you’re proud
of. It is nothing more than 100% pure Kansas. It is hard to pick
one. I would only pick Leftoverture from the overall
picture, from beginning to end. It represents the Kansas heyday.
As most people know Kansas is represented in Leftoverture.