Rating: B+
For those old enough to remember, Journey was a band
long before songs like "Faithfully," "Open Arms" and "Be
Good to Yourself." The band actually started out as a
jazzy, prog type rock band before morphing into the
great, ‘70's melodic hard rock band that featured
newcomer Steve Perry on vocals.
Starting with Escape, Journey took to the
softer side of things and become a worldwide musical
force that mixed Perry's pomp, guitarist Neal Schon's
flair and new keyboard player Jonathan Cain's pop savvy
songwriting. Since Perry's departure, Journey has been
through a few singers and struggled to create a great
classic rock album. They have come close, and even sold
a lot of records but they have failed to make a solid
musical statement, start to finish. With Eclipse,
they have returned as a true band and not just a pop
tour de force going through the motions. Dare I say it?
Journey has new life and is rocking hard.
The band has received praise for stretching out of
the box and going in a new direction, yet to my ears
this is just Journey being Journey. They have taken all
of the past, put it in a blender and made music that has
bits and pieces of all eras and incarnations of the
band, leaning on the heavy guitar oriented 1970's
version of the band. To the dismay of the fans that
swoon and sway to the sugar and sweet ballads, and
benign pop songs, this one has nothing that can be
described as sticky sweet. Instead Journey delivers a
bombastic guitar oriented album. In other words, there
is no lighter waving and making out with your girlfriend
on this album. Well, almost none, the song "Tantra" will
get the lighers out and might just get you a kiss.
Songs like "City of Hope," which is the best Journey
song written since Escape, will have people
rocking out, and sporting a wide toothed grin, as Neal
Schon plays his arse off. "Edge of the Moment" is
another grand musical statement. The album closes with
"Venus" which is nothing more than Neal Schon banging
out killer riff after riff and solo after solo. Neal
jams out on this instrumental, kicking it out with
precision, speed and dexterity not seen since that cool
ass riff at the beginning of "Don't Stop Believing."
Top 40 Journey fans beware, however, as this is not
the hook laden, melodic guitar fest you fell in love
with when you bought Frontiers. The pop hooks are
subtle, the melody is often smashed in the skull by a
killer guitar solo, and there is not even a lot of piano
playing in the forefront. That said, the album is not
devoid of hooks nor melody; it is there, its just not
obvious. This is a very musical album. One can't deny
the classic melody in "Resonate" or "She's a Mystery."
Even the rhythmic guitar leads in "City of Hope" and
"Edge of the Moment" are a reflection of classic
Journey.
Vocalist Anrel Pineda gets huge kudos as he gives a
strong performance from beginning to end. He finds the
melodies within each song, which is harder to do with
complex music than it is with bubble gum. Some songs
don't lend themselves easily to the classic Journey
sound but Arnel finds the right tone on each track.
Jonathan Cain gets a high five for taking a backseat on
this one and allowing the song to call out for what is
needed. The rhythm section of Deen Castronovo and Ross
Valory drive the songs where they need to go as Schon,
as stated, delivers big from beginning to end.
While this is not what one would have expected from
Journey, it is the most adventurous, creative and
powerful album they have made sans Perry. While it
harkens back to Departure, Evolution and
Infinity, it also contains elements of the other
eras of the band. If anything is lost it is the fluff
and cheese that made the band a lot of money but also
garnered them a lot of critical crapola.
I, for one, am happy to hear Journey pushing
themselves, musically, on Eclipse. As Neal Schon
promised on the Journey website when the band recorded
this album, "This one rocks." Yes indeed, I couldn’t
have said it better myself.
By Jeb Wright